Charlie Smith Jr. — Interview Q&A
≈ 6 min read · or listen, or skim the bold lines
B · From the record Summaries are drawn from Cal Nez’s interview. Quotations are not published until checked against the recording. How we verify →
Answer summaries in the site’s words, drawn from the recorded Cal Nez interview (Politics on the Navajo Nation, 2026) — not quotations and not the candidate’s own wording. Their exact words are in the video, linked from their profile.
← Candidate profile · Back to your comparison →
Background
Cal asked: Who are you and where are you from?
Smith is a U.S. military veteran and former police officer from a well-known Navajo broadcasting family, running for the Cameron–Gray Mountain–Birdsprings seat. He raises cattle and says he lived through the 1989 riots, which shaped his view of allegiance and the rule of law.
Roads & Local Priorities
Cal asked: What are the main issues you'd tackle?
Among the long-standing issues he wrote down, Smith puts area road conditions first.
Not sure how to weigh this answer? The five lenses, in brief ▾
- Transparency & accountability: who is responsible, and how would progress be measured and verified?
- Root cause: does this address the underlying problem, or only the symptom?
- Culture — K’é / Hózhǫ: does it strengthen kinship, restore balance, honor future generations?
- Collaboration: who would need to work together — and does the answer name them?
- Prevention vs. damage control: does it prevent harm, or only respond after it?
Veterans
Cal asked: Whose responsibility are veterans, and what would you do?
Smith calls veterans a dual responsibility of the federal government and the Nation; PTSD is real — his son returned from Desert Storm with it. He'd encourage homecoming ceremonies and faith-based or traditional counseling, direct veterans to services, and explore waiving home-site-lease hurdles to get them homes.
Not sure how to weigh this answer? The five lenses, in brief ▾
- Transparency & accountability: who is responsible, and how would progress be measured and verified?
- Root cause: does this address the underlying problem, or only the symptom?
- Culture — K’é / Hózhǫ: does it strengthen kinship, restore balance, honor future generations?
- Collaboration: who would need to work together — and does the answer name them?
- Prevention vs. damage control: does it prevent harm, or only respond after it?
Title 2 & the Window Rock Conflict
Cal asked: How would you address the president-council gridlock?
Smith is familiar with Title 2 — the post-1989 structure, checks and balances, and authority of the government, from which the LGA also derived — and says the fix never fully took hold: in his words, “It's basically, we're back to how it was before.” He'd support updating Title 2 to strengthen its structure and checks. When Cal argued the branches aren't equally balanced and asked whether he'd back the Council relinquishing some power to make them truly equal, Smith said he would — for him it comes down to courage, integrity, and the oath: you decide on principle even when it costs popularity.
Not sure how to weigh this answer? The five lenses, in brief ▾
- Transparency & accountability: who is responsible, and how would progress be measured and verified?
- Root cause: does this address the underlying problem, or only the symptom?
- Culture — K’é / Hózhǫ: does it strengthen kinship, restore balance, honor future generations?
- Collaboration: who would need to work together — and does the answer name them?
- Prevention vs. damage control: does it prevent harm, or only respond after it?
Business Development (His Passion)
Cal asked: How will you grow business in your area?
Business development is Smith's signature issue. When Cal cited the gap — about 1,963 fully Navajo-owned businesses versus more than 91,000 residents commuting to border towns for work — Smith agreed, and in his own telling tied it to dual taxation and to grazing-permit and home-site/business-site lease barriers rooted in the federal trust status of the land. He'd work on the grazing-permit issues to open up home sites, business sites, and alternative energy (solar, wind, hydro), negotiating with the federal government under its trust responsibility.
Not sure how to weigh this answer? The five lenses, in brief ▾
- Transparency & accountability: who is responsible, and how would progress be measured and verified?
- Root cause: does this address the underlying problem, or only the symptom?
- Culture — K’é / Hózhǫ: does it strengthen kinship, restore balance, honor future generations?
- Collaboration: who would need to work together — and does the answer name them?
- Prevention vs. damage control: does it prevent harm, or only respond after it?
Sovereignty & Getting Off Dependency
Cal asked: How do you protect the Nation's future?
Smith frames the treaty as having traded Navajo self-sufficiency for federal promises, warns that federal funding will shrink, and says the Nation must take risks, reform its tax codes, and reduce dependency before treaties or protections are pulled.
Not sure how to weigh this answer? The five lenses, in brief ▾
- Transparency & accountability: who is responsible, and how would progress be measured and verified?
- Root cause: does this address the underlying problem, or only the symptom?
- Culture — K’é / Hózhǫ: does it strengthen kinship, restore balance, honor future generations?
- Collaboration: who would need to work together — and does the answer name them?
- Prevention vs. damage control: does it prevent harm, or only respond after it?
See something to correct? Email a correction.